Skip to content

Why Would A Person Falsely Confess To A Crime?

Why would people confess to a crime when they don't think they committed it? We show you in a few bullet points.

Why you can trust Investigate Midwest
Why Would A Person Falsely Confess To A Crime?
PoliceLine
LISTEN TO THE PODCAST:
  • Dispositional Characteristics

Characteristics such as drug or alcohol abuse, mental illness and suggestibility, common in juveniles who are more apt to want to please adults, make suspects more vulnerable to the pressures of an interrogation and more likely to confess to a crime he/she did not commit.

  • Psychological Vulnerabilities

All humans are susceptible to different psychological vulnerabilities and short-sightedness is one that is very common. Outweighing the short-term benefits over the long-term punishment happens in normal, everyday life. When an interrogation becomes unpleasant, an innocent person could confess in order to escape his/her current situation, concluding he/she can deal with the punishment later. Paired with what is referred to as the Phenomenon of Innocence by Madon, an innocent person might confess in order to get out of the interrogation, while thinking the likelihood of a punishment ever occurring is slim because their innocence will later be proven. Lastly, self-regulatory resources, which are responsible for regulating a person’s behavior, can be diminished by long, stressful situations. A person becomes less capable to override impulses when these resources have been expended, leading to their inability to continue to assert their innocence.

Stephanie Madon
  • Interrogators Use Tactics that Exploit a Psychological Vulnerabilities

Source: Stephanie Madon, psychology professor at Iowa State University

BACK TO MAIN STORY
HOW THE REID TECHNIQUE WORKS
STEPS TO ‘PEACE’ INTERVIEWING

More in Criminal Justice

See all

More from Compiled by Krista Johnson/IowaWatch

See all

THANK YOU TO OUR FUNDERS

Reva & David Logan Foundation, Inasmuch Foundation, Lumpkin Family Foundation, Builders Vision Philanthropy, Gary Marx Journalism Fund, Kirkpatrick Foundation, Chicago Region Food System Fund, Illinois Food Movement Fund, GRACE Communications, Good Chaos, Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute, Fund for Investigative Journalism, Pulitzer Center for Crisis Reporting, Rural News Network, Google News Initiative, Data-Driven Reporting Project, Arnold Ventures.

We are proud to hold the Candid Seal of Transparency, demonstrating our commitment to openness and accountability in all that we do.

MEMBER OF