Skip to content

GRAPHIC: USDA has received almost 1,000 complaints about operations selling ‘organic’ products without certification in recent years

More than half of the investigations resulted in compliance or a civil penalty, according to newly released data.

Why you can trust Investigate Midwest /Content type: Explainer
GRAPHIC: USDA has received almost 1,000 complaints about operations selling ‘organic’ products without certification in recent years
Employees at Maharishi Vedic City Organic Farm adjust hundreds of threads for cucumber vines to grow on unhampered. photo by Donna Schill, for Investigate Midwest

The “organic” label often hikes prices consumers pay at grocery stores, and more and more farms are trying to become organic certified by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. But the increase in popularity can mean the agency has to, in its words, protect the “integrity of the USDA organic seal.”

Since 2019, the USDA has received almost 1,000 complaints that operators selling organic products — i.e., not genetically modified or with the aid of pesticides — were not what they claimed.

More than half of those complaint investigations resulted in compliance and a small amount resulted in civil penalties, according to recently released data.

The National Organic Program has released statistics on its enforcement for years, but, recently, more detailed case-level data was obtained by the Data Liberation Project, which aims to request and publicize datasets the government does not release.

More in Data Harvest

See all

More from Sky Chadde, Investigate Midwest

See all

THANK YOU TO OUR FUNDERS

Reva & David Logan Foundation, Inasmuch Foundation, Lumpkin Family Foundation, Builders Vision Philanthropy, Gary Marx Journalism Fund, Kirkpatrick Foundation, Chicago Region Food System Fund, Illinois Food Movement Fund, GRACE Communications, Good Chaos, Donald W. Reynolds Journalism Institute, Fund for Investigative Journalism, Pulitzer Center for Crisis Reporting, Rural News Network, Google News Initiative, Data-Driven Reporting Project, Arnold Ventures.

We are proud to hold the Candid Seal of Transparency, demonstrating our commitment to openness and accountability in all that we do.

MEMBER OF